Opinion

Ayanna Pressley for Speaker. Period.

By WTFs Next · · 11 min read

In my last post, Congratulations. Now Don’t Hand the Keys Back, I spent a lot of words on why I don’t want Hakeem Jeffries as Speaker, and I barely mentioned Ayanna Pressley for the “okay, but who instead?” part. And an alternative without a defense is just a gripe without substance.

This is the substance. This is the defense. Ayanna Pressley is the alternative. If all you know about her is “the Squad” photo, I’m about to change that. And since you know I like to bring receipts, everything below is linked to its cited source.

Who She Actually Is

Pressley has represented Boston and its surrounding cities since 2019. She got there by beating a longtime Democratic incumbent in a primary where the Congressional Black Caucus’ old guard bet on her opponent.

She WON, then joined the Congressional Black Caucus anyway.

Cook Political Report notes she entered Congress with the most political experience of anyone in the Squad.

She sits on Oversight, where she’s been a prominent voice for Epstein survivors and where Democrats will now run the investigations. She also sits on the Steering and Policy Committee, which helps decide who gets which committee seats.

Translation: she isn’t a protest vote. She’s an insider who kept her principles.

One more thing most people don’t know. Last December she passed on a Senate run, and part of her reasoning was that she wanted to use her seniority to help Democrats win the House majority. We got that majority. She stayed to do the job. OMFG….someone with…gasp…INTEGRITY? (Don’t tell Hakeem…)

Policy: Side by Side

Medicare for All. Pressley ran on it in 2018, cosponsored the 2021 bill, and the week after the election she put it plainly: “Democrats, don’t just talk about health care justice, pass Medicare for All.”

Jeffries cosponsored it too, from 2013 through 2021. Then he became leader. In August he told NBC it’s not legislation he currently cosponsors or supports. His explanation is that it’s about staying neutral as party leader. I get the logic. But a Speaker who goes neutral on the biggest health care fight of the decade, a policy that up to 66% of Americans agree with,  isn’t going to be the one forcing the vote. Pressley has already said she wants the vote.

Abolish ICE. Pressley has said the agency should be abolished, not reformed, not reformatted, not sent to sensitivity training… and she wants Congress to use the power of the purse to rein it in. Jeffries has drawn distinctions between his views and calls to abolish ICE. Whatever you think of the slogan, notice who’s actually proposing to use the power of the purse.

Gaza and Israel. Pressley cosponsored the Ceasefire Now resolution in October 2023 and has pushed for an offensive arms embargo ever since. She also filed an amendment for a one-year moratorium on offensive weapons transfers that kept Iron Dome intact. Jeffries, meanwhile, continued to reject calls for a ceasefire. That’s a real difference on the issue that is splitting the caucus down the middle. Also, Jeffries has received over $1.5 million in campaign contributions from AIPAC and pro-Israel lobby groups over his congressional career, according to tracking data from Track AIPAC and Who Funds My Rep? .

Progressive or moderate? Let’s call it what it is. Jeffries told NBC he doesn’t support Medicare for All or the DSA’s agenda, which Newsweek described as staking out a centrist position. That’s a legitimate lane, and there’s a real argument that it wins swing seats. But voters just handed us a majority, and the question for the next two years is whether the person holding the gavel wants to use it or manage it. Pressley’s answer is use it.

The Votes That Tell You Something

Talk is cheap. Votes aren’t. Here are four where Pressley held a line.

July 15, 2026: the Massie amendment. A Republican offered an amendment to cut $3.3 billion in military aid to Israel. Pressley and the entire Massachusetts delegation voted yes. Jeffries voted no, calling the amendment overly broad because it would cut diplomatic and humanitarian funding too. He didn’t whip, and 103 Democrats voted yes, 98 voted no, and 10 voted present. Even Nancy Pelosi and Whip Katherine Clark voted yes. Jeffries’ concern about the breadth might be a fair one, but on one of the biggest foreign policy votes of the year, the caucus majority went one way and the leader went the other. And it doesnt bode well when that “leader” has taken so much money from PACs who supported a No vote.

April 2024: the Israel aid supplemental. Pressley was one of 37 Democrats to vote no, saying diplomacy and humanitarian aid should come first. The same day she voted yes on the Ukraine package, because stopping Putin was an obligation. So she isn’t a blanket no on military aid. She votes the specifics.

October 2023: right after October 7. She cosponsored the Ceasefire Now resolution on October 16, and she joined a separate resolution condemning Hamas’ attack and demanding the hostages’ release. Then she voted present on a House resolution on October 25, saying the text was dated and left out the overwhelming loss of Palestinian life. That’s not one-sided. It’s a member who reads the text before she votes.

November 2021: infrastructure. She was one of six House Democrats to vote against the bipartisan infrastructure bill, because they wanted it moved together with Build Back Better. Her line on the vote was “Paid leave is infrastructure.” It was a risky vote, and she took heat for it. She cast it anyway.

Follow the Money

Last time I said donations aren’t proof that a vote was bought, and I still think that. But money tells you who a member has to explain themselves to.

Jeffries. According to OpenSecrets data cited by Common Dreams, Pro-Israel America was his largest donor in one recent election, and three of his top five contributors were pro-Israel groups. Sludge reports AIPAC’s PAC has raised more than a million dollars in earmarked donations for him, although AIPAC says its money comes from American citizens. A think-tank analysis of congressional leaders’ fundraising found small donors made up roughly 8% of Jeffries’ 2024 receipts. That’s the best showing among the four leaders, and it’s still tiny.

Pressley. Back in 2019, Sludge found that Squad members like Pressley raised money from thousands of mostly small donors with virtually no corporate PAC help, while the House Democratic leaders took in about $1.2 million from corporate and trade PACs in a single quarter. The PAC checks she does take come from places like the Teamsters, elevator constructors, Planned Parenthood and Indivisible Action. She’s not a monk about it: a $2,000 check from a life insurers’ PAC in 2020 shows up as refunded in 2021, and a law firm PAC chipped in $500. But the pattern is labor and advocacy groups, not Wall Street.

Why it matters. AIPAC spent nearly $30 million in the Michigan Senate primary, its largest investment in a single race. Every member of Congress watched that. Pressley has been publicly critical of that kind of spending and has the votes to match.

I want a Speaker who is fighting for us, not one who is doing math about the next primary.

She Can Actually Legislate (Yes, With Republicans)

If the knock on the left is “all messaging, no bills,” Pressley is a counterexample worth knowing. She’s a founding member of the Black Maternal Health Caucus, and she has a track record to point to:

A Speaker’s job is counting votes and building coalitions across a caucus that runs from Blue Dogs to democratic socialists. A member who has worked with Republicans on legislation and still votes her conscience on Gaza has more of that résumé than people assume.

The Part Where I Argue Against Myself

I’d rather say these out loud than have you find them in the comments.

She hasn’t said she wants the job. As far as I can tell, Pressley hasn’t announced a run for Speaker, and she has been friendly with Jeffries: she praised his election as leader in 2022. Nothing here is a knock on her. It just means this starts with us asking the question, not with her campaign. So I’m hoping and praying….knowing that all I may end this with is hopes and prayers.

Jeffries has the caucus. He was elected leader unanimously in 2022. Mamdani blocked a DSA ally from running against him, and when a reporter asked in August about Jeffries becoming Speaker, he said he continues to support Jeffries’ bid. That’s also the safe thing to say for a mayor who needs the city’s House leader on federal issues, so I don’t read too much into it. Ocasio-Cortez said a primary challenge to the leader isn’t a good idea right now. And he did eventually endorse Mamdani, even if it took months.

Her record has weak spots too. In 2018 she ran on “change can’t wait” and then backed Nancy Pelosi for Speaker. And that infrastructure vote still gets thrown at her.

None of that changes my answer. It changes the strategy. Jeffries starts with the votes, and any alternative has to start with pressure from the people who elected these members who are casting the votes..

What You Can Do (Yes, You)

Same drill as last time, with one new line. The House Democratic caucus picks its nominee before the full House votes for Speaker in January, so the window is the next few weeks.

  1. If your representative is a Democrat, call their office.
  2. Say: “I voted Democratic because I wanted change. Who are you planning to support for Speaker, and have you considered Ayanna Pressley?”
  3. Ask for a name. “I’m listening to my colleagues” is not an answer.
  4. Send this to one friend who lives in a Democratic district.

If your representative is a Republican, they don’t get a say in who leads the Democrats. But you can pass this along to someone whose representative does.

If Democrats did pick her, she’d be the first Black woman to hold the gavel.

That would be history, but I’m not asking for a first.

I’m asking for a Speaker who reads the text, holds the line, and says out loud what the majority is for.

This would give us history AND hope for the future.

We spent years asking Democrats to fight.

Let’s pick someone who is already fighting.

Sources

WTFs Next

Written by

WTFs Next

Sometimes you stand there and think, “WTF’s Next?” while looking at a situation or something on the news. And you’re left to point, fret, wonder and mull it over alone. I instead choose to write all that crap down HERE and get it off my chest.

Leave a Comment